Safeway: Catalina Deal = Skippy Peanut Butter for $1.09!

The links in the post below may be affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Safeway is running a Buy 4, Save $4 sale this week and Skippy Peanut Butter is included in the sale. The great part is that some areas are also running a catalina deal to make the price even better! Here is your scenairo:

Skippy Natural Peanut Butter is $1.59 each wyb 4 *regional price
-$1 Catalina wyb (2) *this catalina deal only runs through 10/29, and it looks like it will print one for every two that you buy
=$1.09 each!

If you do not want four Peanut Butters, here is another option for you:

Buy (2) Skippy Natural Peanut Butter $1.59 each
Buy (2) Bertolli Pasta Sauce $1.49 each *regional price
-.75/2 Bertolli Coupon
-$1 Catalina
=$1.10 each!

Don’t forget that catalina deals can be regional. Please let us know if it works for you!

Make sure to check out the complete list of Safeway Deals  before heading out to the store too.

(Thanks My Frugal Adventures  for the deal and photo!)


  1. Charlotte says

    Hmmm they were marked $2.59 at my store too so I decided not to try it. There is a Target coupon for $.75 off Planters Peanut Butter and it was $1.99 at my Target so a better deal. Maybe I should try it anyway and see what happens though.

  2. Diane Mc says

    I went on my lunch break today and bought 4. They rang up at $2.59 and no $4 credit showed up (Buy 4, get $4 off). 2 catalina printed for $1 ea. Went to customer service and they gave me the $4 in cash. Still ended up paying $1.09 + tax each. Love peanut butter!!!

    • Mommy Kane says

      Patty I just went to the Monument Safeway and it was the $1.59 price, unfortuntely I wanted the natural and someone swipped all of that already, but they had the regular and chunky in good supply.

  3. kimberly downham says

    went last night and the shelf price was buy 4 for 1.59 each.
    this morning it was buy 4 for 2.59 each (3.59 otherwise)- i dont understand why they upped the price on the 2nd day of the ad.

  4. Mommy Kane says

    Oh I am so excited, I have been waiting for a good deal on pb as we are just about out from stocking up on the planters a while back. This is great that it includes the natural skippy. I have tried this and it taste the same to me, plus it uses no hydrogenated oils, so that is a plus, especially at this price!
    Thanks Jennie, yet again!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *